NatWest Accelerator Events Free one-day marketing seminar at the NatWest Accelerator, Milton Keynes · 10 November 2026 Free marketing seminar · NatWest Accelerator, Milton Keynes · 10 Nov 2026 Free seminar · 10 Nov 2026
NatWest Accelerator, MK
Get your free invite →Invite →

Home › Blog › Digital Marketing

Digital Marketing

Why Your Email Marketing Isn’t Working (And How to Fix It)

Why Your Email Marketing Isn’t Working (And How to Fix It)
Read the video transcript

How do I make email marketing actually work? Good question. All right. So, here's what I would do is first of all, segment your list. Send different emails to customers, to leads, and to cold subscribers because relevance skyrockets your engagement. The way we talk differently to our parents, to our friends, to our children is the same way you would talk to your customers, to your cold lead who has just subscribed and downloaded the lead magnet or somebody who has already become a a lead and has been on your email list for a while.

The other way to segment is by services. So if let's say for example you are running an insurance company and you do car insurance, home insurance, business insurance, content insurance and so on. So you got to segment the list so that people who are interested in car insurance only get offers and information about car insurance and not about any other kind of insurance because you can send it to them but more likely they're going to unsubscribe very quickly. uh write subject lines that creates curiosity.

So avoid, you know, words like newsletter wibes. Use curiosity like you're missing this one thing uh in your funnel. So make them curious to open up that um email. Another thing u you should do is use a simple structure. And the structure is you got to have a hook, a story, and the offer with a call to action.

If you follow this structure, you're going to get better performance with your email marketing. So, people read stories, not sales pitches all the time. They're interested in your story and start with the pain or story. Then lead them to your offer naturally. Um, another tip I can give you is um, automate your follow-ups. Don't just rely on one email because most of the time people don't open up the emails and you know how many emails we all get every day.

So it's so much noise in our inboxes at the moment that you got to do something different and do it consistently. So your name keeps popping up on their laptop, on their mobile device, on their computers and everywhere. But don't spam them either and cheese them off by sending lots of emails. When somebody signs up to your lead magnet, uh create a email sequence of three to five emails that builds trust and gives value before you send out any pricing or before you send them to book a call with you or to buy something from you.

And one more thing I shall add is test one variable at a time. What I mean by this is change one element per test. So for example, it could be the subject line, the call to action or the image in the header of that email. So you know what's actually improving performance or not. So if you are using something like Mailchimp, you can AB test.

So you can send half the email to one with a different image and half the email to another um half your uh subscribers with the another image on it and that will show you which was the winner and which was the loser. And then you start going along the route of the kind of images or headlines or the email actually which people uh like and open up.

Email marketing sounds easy, but most people get it wrong. They send one generic message to everyone on their list and then wonder why their open rates are terrible. The truth is, good email marketing is about sending the right message to the right people at the right time.

Here’s how to make that actually happen without overcomplicating it.

Free NatWest Accelerator event

Get Found, Get Chosen, Get Your Time Back

A free one-day marketing seminar in Milton Keynes · 10 November 2026

Get your free invite →

1. Segment Your List

Not everyone on your list should get the same email.

Get your free Marketing Action PlanNot sure where to start? Answer a few questions and get your plan in about a minute. No email needed.

Get my plan →

Think of it this way, you don’t talk to your parents the same way you talk to your friends, right?

Your emails should work the same way.

Split your list into smaller groups based on who they are and what they want. For example:

  • Customers – people who’ve already bought something.
  • Leads – people interested but not yet customers.
  • Cold subscribers – people who just signed up or haven’t engaged in a while.

You can also segment by product or service. If you sell car insurance, don’t send business insurance emails to someone who only wants car insurance. Relevance matters. It’s what keeps people opening your emails instead of hitting “unsubscribe.”

2. Write Subject Lines That Create Curiosity

Your subject line decides whether your email even gets opened. Avoid boring stuff like “Monthly Newsletter” or “Update from Us.” Instead, write something that makes people curious, like:

  • “You’re missing this one thing in your strategy”
  • “I made this mistake last week…”

Keep it conversational, short, and a little mysterious. The goal is to make people want to click.

Uzair KharawalaLIVE
Free weekly YouTube live

Live every Tuesday at 2pm UK. Bring your marketing questions.

Get your Google, local SEO and AI questions answered live.

Join for free

3. Use a Simple Structure

Don’t overthink the content of your emails. A simple format works best:

  1. Hook: Start with something that grabs attention.
  2. Story: Share a short story, example, or relatable situation.
  3. Offer/Call to Action: End with what you want them to do next (book a call, read a blog post, buy your product, etc.).

People enjoy reading stories more than sales pitches. If you can connect emotionally first, your offer will feel more natural.

4. Automate Your Follow-Ups

Don’t stop after one email. People are busy and miss things.

Set up an automated sequence, maybe 3 to 5 emails, to build trust before you pitch anything. Give value first: share tips, stories, or insights that help your audience. Then, once they know and trust you, introduce your offer.

Automation tools like Mailchimp, ConvertKit, or ActiveCampaign make this super easy to set up.

5. Test One Thing at a Time

If you want to improve your emails, test them, but keep it simple. Change one thing per test:

  • Try a different subject line
  • Change the main image
  • Tweak the call-to-action

This way, you’ll know what made a difference instead of guessing. Most email tools have A/B testing built in, so take advantage of that.

Final Thoughts

Email marketing only works when it’s personal, consistent, and intentional. Segment your list, tell better stories, follow up automatically, and keep testing.

You don’t need fancy tools or long campaigns, just clear communication and a bit of consistency. When you treat your subscribers like real people (not just inboxes), your results will start to change.

Uzair Kharawala

Written by Uzair Kharawala

Partner at SF Digital Studios, a Google Premier Partner agency. Uzair has been helping businesses grow with Google Ads since 2002 and teaches it every week on YouTube.

Book A Call →Subscribe on YouTube for new videos every weekday →
Free every week

Get our best Google Ads tips by email

New articles and videos, straight to your inbox. Unsubscribe any time.

We respect your privacy at all times. Privacy Policy

You may also like

Read the blog →

Your next customers are out there. Let's go and get them.

Tell us where you want your business to be, and we'll show you how to get there.

Book A Call →or get your free Google Health Check →
Happy clients

Don't take our word for it

4.9 from 157 Google reviews, plus case studies and client videos.

See our happy clients →
"It has now been 3 months since we started and our sales have increased 300%."
Ruhi Latif Rafplay, Dubai
"Uzair and Farzana are two of the most honest, sincere and trustworthy people you will ever meet."
Gavin Morgan GDM Jewellery · Google review
"If I needed a campaign built, this is one of the rare few people IN THE WORLD I would trust to do it properly."
Hemmel Amrania Google Ads professional · Google review
Book A Call →
Chat with us on WhatsApp