I'm Keith Flanagan, and I've been working closely with enterprise architects and technologists since 2010. During this time I've helped thousands of professionals from all over the world to understand the value and benefits of soft skills development. Given that a significant part of a senior architect's or IT manager's day is routinely spent dealing with people, there's a clear requirement that behavioural competencies form a hugely important part of their success.
And although opinions to support this has more recently been generally accepted, I'm often still quite surprised that so little investment is being made to develop many of our professionals in these critical areas. Because in organisations where investments in training, coaching, profiling and team development is being made, architects and technologists are reaping the rewards through the creation of stronger engagement with their teams and with their stakeholders, many of whom are relied upon to sponsor and support their projects.
I believe that one reason for this reluctance to embrace the importance of soft skills is that the world of technology, be it IT or architecture, is largely dominated by men. When I launched the developmental program for technologists with the words "soft skills" in the title, it attracted some peripheral interest but little in the way of commitment through sign up. Whereas when the term soft skills was removed, the program gained a lot more traction with male technologists, despite the contents of the program remaining largely unchanged.
It's probable, then, that the male perception of the term soft skills, when seen as a set of intangible behavioural competencies, may have their benefits, the label soft skills may not be quite as palatable, especially for technologists.
Another aspect to this theory is the subject of personality or psychometric profiling. Many technologists have told me that they are dismissive of, if not uncomfortable with, any form of profiling, as they view it as being too subjective or even fluffy. I believe there are two possible reasons why technologists may hold this opinion.
The first is that many traditional technologists have preferred to concentrate on hard facts, science and evidence; that profiling, without consideration of every single detail or variable, can never be truly accurate and probably should be dismissed. Second, and perhaps more sadly, is that many of the clients that I have worked with who had been exposed to profiling had either a bad experience due to the poor standards of the profiling practitioner, or that once profiling had taken place, the results were never used for any sustained developmental gain.
However, for me as a leadership consultant, the question arises: how can anyone really know how they are perceived by others without some form of proven insight into their own behavioural characteristics? This doesn't necessarily advocate all forms of psychometric profiling; rather, the appropriate form of profiling, carried out by an appropriate practitioner, with the outcomes being put to good use.
Whatever label you wish to use, the development of soft skills in many of the professionals that I have worked with has been of tremendous benefit. In Eastern Europe, for example, a practice of architects were continually fighting through barriers with governmental departments due to the somewhat bureaucratic nature of the organisational culture.
However, following the continued use of soft skills developed by undertaking a program designed specifically for technologists, many reported breaking new ground with their previously resistant stakeholders and secured an appetite for buy-in to architecture projects that had never existed before. Many of the architecture teams found themselves in positions of much greater influence at senior levels through the open use of skills such as empathy, collaboration, change leadership and communication.
Ultimately, this particular architecture practice became a high performing and cohesive team that was widely regarded as a much valued asset, as opposed to being looked upon as a group of technologists with only their own interests at heart. Similar results were witnessed within the public and private organisations in the US, Canada, New Zealand and the UK.
Technology teams and architecture practices that adopted the use of soft skills were seeing very real benefits by changing their approach to stakeholders at all levels across the business. Also interesting was that many had reported they were enjoying much more personal satisfaction from their work, and that their working environments had changed for the better due to a greater focus on workplace empathy. Many said that they felt better supported by their managers to provide a great service.
In essence, we were helping to create great places to work, which would result in lower staff turnover, less sickness absence and higher levels of morale, all leading to great performance. Greater engagement at all levels of stakeholder meant that key figures were buying into the value of architecture and technology, because they had an emotional stake in the process.
I don't believe that anybody goes to work to do a bad job, but I do believe that soft skills not only create great technologists and architects, they also produce great leaders and role models. Now, which one of us doesn't want to be one of those?